is slice the pie legit logo
Product Reviews A-Z

Is Slice The Pie legit or a scam? Can you really make money from it?

I’ve liked some of the songs I heard on Slice The Pie and some of the songs weren’t quite my cup of tea. Slice The Pie is a service that pays you for your opinion on various songs.

If you fancy yourself as a bit of a music critic and love discovering new music, Slice The Pie will pay you for sharing your opinion.

But how much can you really make money with Slice The Pie?

What Is Slice the Pie all about?

Is Slice The Pie legit or a scam

Slice The Pie is a service that matches independent recording artists with reviewers (i.e. everyday music critics like you and me).

Music critics are required to listen to at least 90 seconds of a music track, give it a rating from 1 to 10 and leave a written review of at least 60 words.

Compared to usual survey sites like Swagbucks and Opinion World that require you to tick through boxes, Slice The Pie is a breath of fresh air.

Because I enjoy writing, I initially quite enjoyed writing the mini reviews. It was more interesting than simply ticking the boxes and answering the same old survey questions.

So how much do you get paid?

When you first join, you will be given a star rating of one.

Is Slice The Pie legit or a scam


However, if you stick around for a while and do more review you can earn more stars.

As you increase in star ratings, you can earn more per review.

Can You Really Make Money with Slice the Pie?

Having a poke around the internet, I didn’t find many people who seemed to be making good money from Slice The Pie but I decided to open my own account at Slice the Pie and find out for myself.

Sign up Process

To sign up I simply went into the main website and clicked on ‘sign up now’.

Is Slice The Pie legit or a scam

I was then taken to this simple sign up form. Once you fill it in, you will need to find the activation email in your inbox and press ‘confirm’ the email address provided to activate your account.

Is Slice The Pie legit or a scam

When you sign up will be asked if you want to review music, fashion, mobile or a lucky dip. However, I was only able to select either music or lucky dip.

Perhaps the other ones weren’t avaliable just yet.

Is Slice The Pie legit or a scam

You will then be asked a few personal questions like your martial status, whether you are working full-time or part-time etc.

At the end you are asked to choose your top three favourite genres of music from a LONG list of genres:

Is Slice The Pie legit or a scam

After choosing three genres, you will then be asked to move through the other genres to rate them on a scale from 1 to 10.

Is Slice The Pie legit or a scam

That’s pretty much it for the sign up process. Once you do that you are ready to start listening and reviewing.

The Music Review Process

Once I completed the sign up process, I was immediately taken to a music review page. All I had to do was hit ‘play’ to start listening.

While I was listening, I quickly typed in my observations e.g. my thoughts on the quality of the production, vocals, beat, melody.

Working through that list to complete my review made it easy to exceed 60 words and it also took more than the mandatory 90 seconds to type up my written review.

Is Slice The Pie legit or a scam

Just to recap, to complete the music review:

  • You need to listen to 90 seconds of music (you can start writing at the same time as you listen),
  • You must type a review of at least 60 words to be accepted.
  • You have to rate the song on a scale from 1 to 10.

That’s it!

After you submit, the money will be credited to your Slice The Pie account.

So how much do you get per music review?

Is Slice The Pie legit or a scam

I don’t know about you, but 1 cent did not excite me one bit.

I was like, “Are you kidding me?”

Let me do the math.

I think I was pretty quick typing up my review while listening to the piece of music. So let’s say I took 2 minutes to complete a review. If I continued at that speed and didn’t take any breaks for an hour, I would earn 30 cents.

Yes, 30 CENTS PER HOUR! That is much less than any minumum wage job out there.

I don’t know about you but I think my time is worth a lot more than that!

The problem with doing music reviews for one hour straight

I suspect that after doing music review straight for 30 minutes, you might start to struggle to come up music terminology or something fresh to say about the song unless you have a true passion and appreciation for music.

You might find that after a few reviews, you need to take more time to come up with something worthwhile to say.

Slice The Pie has an algorithm that matches your written review with the rating that you have given. It scans your review for particular words.

For example, if you give a review with negative words but a raving 9 star rating, you will get a message telling you that your rating has varied significantly from the review that you gave.

Slice The Pie is also quite picky when it comes to their reviews and if the quality of your review drops after doing them for an hour straight, you might receive an email like this (other users certainly have):

“We hope you’re enjoying reviewing. We’ve noticed your reviews can be quite disjointed which makes them difficult to read. Please note that your reviews go straight to artists and so we’d encourage you to write lengthy, detailed and constructive reviews that comment on a number of aspects of the track. For example: beat, melody, instruments, vocals, production, commercial potential etc. The following article was written by one of our scouts and will help you to improve your reviews:”

Do also note that when you come to cash out, your reviews are sent to be reviewed by an ACTUAL human.

This means if you have not been writing appropriate reviews,  you risk having your reviews rejected and not getting paid for all your hard work.


My Final Opinion on Slice The Pie

Overall this site is definitely legitimate and if you have always wanted to satisfy your inner music critic, this can be a fun way to pass some time.

What you have to note is that Slice The Pie is for people who truly appreciate music NOT for people looking for a paycheck!

The process of listening to the song and actually coming up with meaning and constructive feedback can be pretty time-consuming. And at 1 cent per review, it sure isn’t a great money churner by a long shot.

A Way to Earn Much More With Your Reviews

A better way to do businessWriting for other people is usually a great way to make money online. If you were to try your hand at freelance writing on for example you can expect to be paid $5 for a 500-word article.

That is much more than Slice the Pie will pay, but it is nothing compared to the business model I am about to show you.

Your opinions will earn you a better return if you build a website and create quality content for it. That will be creating an additional stream of income that will earn you passive income.

Your website can be about anything you like. So, if you love fitness, you can write about your favorite tips to keep fit and healthy and your favorite health products.

You could talk about the recipes that you love or the sporting apparel that you love. The options as to what you could talk about is endless!

So how do you make money with a website?

Well, there are many ways and here is just one example.

Let’s say you wrote a 1,000-word review of your favorite exercise machine sold on Amazon for $250. If someone goes to Amazon through your website and buys the machine AND anything else, you earn a commission of 6%. That’s at least $15 in your pocket!

Once you publish your article, it will be available on the internet for people to browse (forever), click on your affiliate links and purchase the product on the merchant’s website.

I note that you are not selling anything, you are just directing people to Amazon’s website.

At the end of the month, you have the potential to make thousands of dollars with many articles targeting different products!

This business model is called affiliate marketing and is one of the most profitable ways to make money online.

If you want to start your affiliate marketing business, then check out my #1 recommendation review below. The first 10 lessons are completely free and will definitely put you on the right track to succeed online.

Check Out My #1 Recommendation here>>

Previous Post Next Post

You Might Also Like


  • Reply Ed November 28, 2017 at 1:02 am

    Hi Shan,
    Great review of Slice The Pie. I have music in my background having played bass in a symphony orchestra, a jazz band, and a rock group. So I thought that listening to music and getting paid to write about it would be fun.
    However, reading your article convinced me that listening to good music while writing a blog is just as much, if not more, fun and much more profitable.
    Thanks for the good advice.

    • Reply Shan November 28, 2017 at 1:05 am

      Hi Ed

      With such a strong musical background you will be the perfect candidate to share your expertise via a blog. If you share tips and tricks and include some reviews of your favourite music products, you could be on your way to a winner.

      If you want to get started with this business model, this is the free starter course I highly recommend to get you started on the right track.

  • Reply Jacqueline December 5, 2017 at 7:56 pm

    The payout is really low and as we know time is money. Who would want to do this? Like you said someone who is passionate about music and maybe someone who is looking to sign an up and coming artist. This could be a way to find them.

    I like your alternative recommendation – Wealthy Affiliate; this seems more plausible in achieving my ultimate goal of being my own boss and generating a steady stream of income.

    I have done surveys in the past but find them laborious and repetitive. It seems with Affiliate Marketing, the options are limitless and it sounds like a great way to make money.

    It’s an eye-opener when you estimate how long it’ll take to make a decent amount of money through slice the pie. For me, it’s just not worth my time and effort.

    • Reply Shan December 5, 2017 at 11:14 pm

      I totally agree Jacqueline!

      For me, affiliate marketing make a lot more sense. And if you want to check out Wealthy Affiliate, the free starter course will explain how affiliate marketing works and start you off on the right track. Its completely free and no credit card is required. That’s how I got started online and I highly recommend it.

    Leave a Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.